by
Damien F. Mackey
“Neo-Assyrian
royal inscriptions (e.g., Adad-nirari III Saba’a Stele)
record
enforced fasts, public mourning, and the participation of livestock
in
ritual purification during national crises —
precisely
the actions described in Jonah 3:6–8”.
To the following interesting
article from biblehub.com I shall be adding a few comments of my own:
What
historical evidence supports the events described in Jonah 3?
Introduction
What historical evidence
supports the events described in Jonah 3?
JONAH 3:9 – HISTORICAL
CORROBORATION OF NINEVEH’S REPENTANCE
Canonical Integrity and Dating
The book of Jonah is attested in the Dead Sea Scrolls
(4QXIIa, c. 150 BC) and the Ketuvim of the Masoretic Text, with virtual textual
unanimity in Jonah 3. 2
Kings 14:25 fixes Jonah’s career
during the reign of Jeroboam II (793–753 BC, Usshurian chronology 790–749 BC),
placing the Nineveh mission in the mid-eighth century before Christ—coincident
with a well-documented era of Assyrian instability.
Damien
Mackey’s comment:
I fully accept that the Book of Jonah is an historical document, and that the
Jonah incident really happened.
But the
Usshurian chronology is now, I believe, well out of date.
The
long-lived prophet Jonah, indeed a contemporary of King Jeroboam II - albeit a
much younger one - well outlived that king of Israel, long after whose death
Jonah would proclaim in Nineveh.
For my
comprehensive version of the prophet, see e.g. my article:
De-coding
Jonah
The article continues:
Archaeological Confirmation of Nineveh’s Setting
Excavations at the mounds of Kuyunjik and Nebi Yunus,
beginning with A. H. Layard (1845–1854) and continued by Christian
archaeologists such as H. Rassam and more recent work by the British Institute
for the Study of Iraq, have uncovered:
• A city circuit wall over 12 km in length with an
inhabited “triangle” of suburbs matching the “three-days’ journey” breadth (Jonah
3:3).
• Administrative tablets from the reigns of
Adad-nirari III and Ashur-dan III, demonstrating an intact bureaucracy capable
of issuing empire-wide decrees of fasting.
• The “Nebi Yunus” mound, long venerated in local
Christian tradition as the burial-site of Jonah, attesting to an enduring
memory of the prophet’s presence.
Political and Psychological Climate of Assyria
(765–759 BC)
Assyrian Eponym Canon entries (ed. Millard, Tyndale
House) record:
• 765 BC: “Plague throughout the land.”
• 763 BC: “Bur-Sagale eclipse” (15 June), a total
solar eclipse visible over Nineveh.
• 762 BC: “Revolt in the city of Ashur.”
• 759 BC: “Second plague.”
Ancient omen texts (Enūma Anu Enlil 20) interpret
eclipses and epidemics as divine wrath, commonly eliciting royal acts of
penitence. Thus, a population already shaken by eclipse, plague, and revolt
forms a historically credible backdrop for the sweeping repentance depicted
in Jonah 3.
Damien
Mackey’s comment:
This admittedly dramatic set of circumstances is not the proper “backdrop” for
the Book of Jonah. My Jonah article tells of a significantly later era for the
Jonah incident.
The article continues:
Royal Decrees of Sackcloth and Animal Involvement
Neo-Assyrian royal inscriptions (e.g., Adad-nirari III
Saba’a Stele) record enforced fasts, public mourning, and the participation of
livestock in ritual purification during national crises—precisely the actions
described in Jonah 3:6–8.
The inclusion of beasts therefore reflects established Assyrian religious
protocol, not narrative embellishment.
Damien Mackey’s comment: This is excellent.
In a
follow-up article I hope to show that Adad-Nirari so-called III was, indeed,
Jonah 3:6’s “king of Nineveh” – but a greatly revised Adad-Nirari
contemporaneous with a my revised prophet Jonah.
The article continues:
Size and Status of the “Great City”
Jonah
3:3 calls Nineveh “an
exceedingly great city, a three-day journey in extent”. Combining the
inner-wall circuit, outlying administrative towns (Rebia, Tarbisu, Kahlu), and
the canal network gives a populated region of roughly 1,500 km², consistent
with a three-day circumference trek at ancient travel rates. Sennacherib’s
later inscriptions boast of “the great city whose splendor surpasses all
lands,” corroborating the biblical superlative.
Damien
Mackey’s comment:
By the time of Jonah’s mission to Nineveh, Sargon II’s mighty city of Dur
Sharrukin was standing in all of its glory. Owing to my identification of
Sargon II (who was also Sennacherib) with Tukulti-Ninurta I, I have been able
to fuse, as one, the brand new city of Dur Sharrukin with the city,
Kar-Tukulti-Ninurta:
Important
city Kar-Tukulti-Ninurta hidden in Mesopotamian geography
(6) Important city
Kar-Tukulti-Ninurta hidden in Mesopotamian geography
The overall
Nineveh complex was “exceedingly great” by the time Jonah arrived there.
The article continues:
Absence from Annals Explained
Assyrian annals uniformly omit military failures and
episodes that embarrass the throne. Their silence on a mass submission to
Israel’s God is exactly the kind of omission expected under official
propagandistic practice (cf. the lack of any Assyrian notice of the angelic
destruction of Sennacherib’s army in 2
Kings 19).
Damien
Mackey’s comment:
While it is beyond the scope of this present article, I do hope to show in
future articles that there are some Assyrian references to this major
disaster for them, so poorly understood by Bible commentators.
And it may
provide the historical backdrop, in part, for the Book of Jonah.
The article continues:
Later Jewish and Early Christian Testimony
• Tobit 14:4–8 (LXX) recounts Nineveh’s pending
judgment, presupposing familiarity with Jonah’s earlier warning.
• Jesus cites Nineveh’s repentance as historical
precedent, “The men of Nineveh will stand up at the judgment” (Matthew
12:41), invoking eyewitness authority
rooted in omniscience.
• Church Fathers (e.g., Jerome, Commentary on Jonah)
treat the conversion as factual history and appeal to its apologetic value
against paganism.
Damien Mackey’s comment: For possible meaningful
contact between Jonah and the Israelites exiled in Nineveh, see my recent
article:
Book
of Tobit provides template for the geography of Job-Tobias
(7) Book of Tobit
provides template for the geography of Job-Tobias
The article continues:
Continuity with Assyrian Religious Reform Movements
Adad-nirari III’s 796 BC conquest stele speaks of
turning to “one god’s worship,” an unusual monotheistic tone suggesting either
Yahwistic influence or at minimum a temporary softening of polytheism—resonant
with a city-wide acceptance of Jonah’s message.
Damien
Mackey’s comment:
This, again, is excellent, and is most relevant to pious Hebrew influences upon
“the king of Nineveh”.
The article continues:
Prophetic Pattern of Conditional Judgment
Jeremiah
18:7–8 sets a covenant
principle: if a nation repents, God relents. Jonah
3:9 records the Assyrian king
echoing that exact logic, “Who knows? God may turn and relent…”. The coherence
of this principle across prophetic literature supports the authenticity of the
event.
No comments:
Post a Comment